Stride Post Latest News
Related Articles
As family dynamics change and society standards vary, the conventional concept of shared parental responsibility in custody agreements is being significantly transformed. In Australia, the challenges of post-separation parenting have prompted a rethinking of custody management, with a shift towards tailored solutions that take into account each family’s individual circumstances.
This blog post discusses the evolving nature of family law in Australia, such as shared parenting obligations following separation or divorce, as well as the value of Family Law CPD. It focuses on the idea that traditional models are not always the greatest fit for current family dynamics, and it suggests legal changes that prioritise the child’s best interests while encouraging flexible arrangements.
Traditionally, shared parental responsibility required both parents to have an equal say in significant decisions impacting their child’s well-being, such as education, health care, and religious upbringing. However, the word “equal input” has occasionally been misconstrued as requiring an equal proportion of time with the child, leading to lengthy and contentious legal battles.
In recent years, there has been an increasing realisation that equitable time-sharing may not be necessarily beneficial to children. The child’s age, attachment to each parent, the distance between the parents’ residences, and the parent’s ability to communicate successfully are all important factors when deciding on the best arrangement. The emphasis is rapidly shifting away from fixed time schedules and towards flexible, child-centred solutions that address each family’s changing requirements.
A Long-Awaited Amendment to the Bill
Introduced in March 2023, the Bill quickly passed through both chambers of Parliament before receiving Royal Assent in November 2023. The most significant changes went into effect on May 6, 2024. This change is based on recommendations made by the Australian Law Change Commission (ALRC), which specifically addressed concerns about children’s rights and legislative simplification.
A Shift from Presumption to Encouragement
The Family Law Amendment Bill 2023 (“the Bill”) fundamentally changes Australia’s family law system. In particular, it repeals the “equal shared parental responsibility” presumption established by the Family Law Act 1975 (Cth) (“the Act”). This presumption, mandated in 2006, was legislated to ensure that both parents stayed involved in their children’s lives. However, concerns arose that it:
- Misled parents: The term “equal” created a misconception that parents were entitled to equal time with the child, regardless of the child’s best interests.
- Hindered settlements: Parties might focus on achieving “equal shared parental responsibility” for legal reasons, rather than what truly benefited the child.
- Ignored safety concerns: In cases involving family violence or abuse, requiring equal decision-making could be dangerous.
The Bill replaces the presumption with a focus on “joint decision-making about major long-term issues” (s 61DAA). This clarifies that parents are encouraged to consult on significant matters impacting the child’s well-being, such as education, healthcare, and religious upbringing.
A New Framework for Parenting Arrangements
The Bill introduces a brand new framework for determining parenting arrangements after separation. Applicable to all new and existing proceedings commencing after 6th May 2024 (except those already at the final hearing stage), this framework represents a significant shift in approach.
Prioritising the Child’s Safety and Wellbeing
The Bill places the child’s safety first by creating a new consideration for courts to consider: “What arrangements promote the safety of the child and the child’s carers, including safety from family violence, abuse, neglect, or other harm” (section 60CC(2)(a)). This ensures that the child’s welfare is the main priority in all decisions.
Simplifying the Framework and Empowering Parents
The Bill streamlines the factors courts consider when determining parenting arrangements. It removes factors like financial contributions and practical difficulties associated with spending time with both parents. This simplifies the process and allows courts to focus on the child’s needs.
The Bill also encourages parents to resolve disputes outside of court through “amicable dispute resolution” (TEN Paper: Family Law Reform Bill, Christie J current 19 February 2024). This gives parents the ability to make adjustments to solutions that work best for their own family situation.
Strengthening the Voice of the Child
The Bill emphasises the importance of incorporating a child’s views in legal proceedings, ensuring their perspectives are acknowledged and valued. Historically, courts considered a child’s opinion, but the Bill explicitly mandates that “any views expressed by the child” must be taken into account (s 60CC(2)(b)). This provision guarantees that a child’s voice is heard, recognising their right to participate in decisions that affect their lives. The weight given to these opinions will vary based on factors such as the child’s maturity and age, acknowledging that younger children may have different levels of understanding and articulation. This approach aligns with international standards on children’s rights, promoting a more inclusive and child-centered legal process. By mandating the consideration of children’s views, the Bill seeks to foster a more responsive and empathetic judicial system, ultimately ensuring better outcomes for young individuals.
The Role of Independent Children’s Lawyers
It is imperative that independent children’s lawyers represent the best interests of the child. The Bill clarifies their duties, including meeting with the child (unless exceptional circumstances exist) and providing them with an opportunity to express their views (s 68LA).
The Importance of Family Law CPD
Legal practitioners need to attend Family Law Conferences and complete Family Law CPD in order to stay up to date on these important changes. These courses are critical for understanding and navigating the changing legal landscape, allowing practitioners to effectively advocate for their clients’ best interests in court. Participating in Legal CPD provides professionals with the knowledge and skills required to manage difficult custody matters, as well as encouraging the development of more just and successful family law practices.
A Brighter Future For Families
The Family Law Amendment Bill 2023 heralds a new era for family law in Australia. The Bill seeks to create a more responsive and child-centred system by rejecting the concept of equal shared parental responsibility in favour of the child’s protection, decision-making, and voice. This will ideally result in more equitable outcomes for separated families and guarantee that the child’s best interests are at the very heart of all decisions.
